About
Foundational Principles In the Community Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Technical Excellence Alumni TIAG Membership
Careers
Why Cohen & Co Our Culture Total Rewards & Benefits Early Career Opportunities Experienced Opportunities Join Our Talent Community
Contact
Akron, OH Baltimore, MD Buffalo, NY Chicago, IL Cleveland, OH Deer Park, IL Denver, CO Detroit, MI Milwaukee, WI New York, NY Philadelphia, PA Pittsburgh, PA St. Clair Shores, MI Youngstown, OH
Client Portal
Services Industries Knowledge Center People

About Our Services

We offer tailored solutions — whether private company or owner; public or private fund, adviser or fund service provider; or Fortune 1000 enterprise. Learn how we can help you.

Find Services

Assurance Services

Employee Benefit Plan Audits Internal Controls Investment Company Audits Private Company Audits

Tax Services

Federal Tax Planning & Compliance High Net Worth & Wealth Transfer International Filings & Structuring Investment Company Tax State & Local Tax Tax Credits & Incentives Transaction Tax Planning

Advisory Services

Business Valuations Data & Insights Digital Finance Solutions IT Strategy & Implementation Litigation Support Services M&A Advisory Outsourced Accounting Solutions Transaction Services Turnaround & Restructuring

Our Industry Expertise

Our industry experience means you can find professionals who speak your language and bring earned insights to the table. Learn how we can help you.

Explore Industries

Key Industries

Digital Assets Investment Companies Manufacturing Private Companies Private Equity Real Estate & Construction Technology & Life Science
VIEW THE COMPLETE LIST

Knowledge Center

Our team wants to help your team stay up to date. Browse our thought leadership, events and news for insights and a point of view on business-critical topics.

Find Insights & Events

Insights

Browse valuable articles and publications our experts have written to help you and your organization answer key questions — and consider new ones.

Read Our Insights

Events

Join us in person and online for events that address timely topics and key business considerations.

Explore Our Events

News

Find out what is happening at Cohen & Co, from industry recognitions and growth updates, to where we are contributing to important media stories.

Read Our News
People
Foundational Principles In the Community Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Technical Excellence Alumni TIAG Membership
Why Cohen & Co Our Culture Total Rewards & Benefits Early Career Opportunities Experienced Opportunities Join Our Talent Community
Akron, OH Baltimore, MD Buffalo, NY Chicago, IL Cleveland, OH Deer Park, IL Denver, CO Detroit, MI Milwaukee, WI New York, NY Philadelphia, PA Pittsburgh, PA St. Clair Shores, MI Youngstown, OH
Client Portal
Back to Insights

U.S. Court Unexpectedly Overturns Entire SEC Private Fund Rule: What Now? 

by Syed Farooq

June 07, 2024 Investment Company Audits, Alternative Investment Funds, Fund Service Providers

In a somewhat unexpected ruling this past Wednesday, a Louisiana U.S. appeals court overturned in its entirety an SEC finalized rule adopted in August 2023. The rule, which amended the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, was intended to provide more protection to investors and transparency into non-registered private funds. It also would have required advisers of private funds to spend additional, significant administrative time and resources to comply. While some in the industry may have expected the rule to be partially vacated, its compete reversal came as a surprise to many.

Historically, hedge funds, private equity funds, venture capital funds and commodity pools, which make up the roughly $30 trillion private fund industry, have enjoyed lower compliance requirements than mutual funds and exchange-traded funds in the registered funds space. This often results in lower operating costs and less burdensome disclosure requirements for private funds. The new August rule stood to change that balance. Learn more about the court’s decision and what it means for funds and advisers.

Which Part of the Private Fund Rule Was Overturned?

The three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit unanimously stated that no part of the private funds rule adopted by the SEC on August 23, 2023, can stand. As a refresher, the rule included:

  • Additional quarterly reporting. The rule required statements to disclose fees, expenses, standardized performance information, along with criteria used and assumptions made to calculate this information in tabular format.
  • Required annual audits. This applied to all private funds advised by registered investment advisers (RIAs), even those funds historically covered by exemptions under the custody rule.
  • Required fairness/valuation opinions. These were required to be obtained from independent providers for adviser-led secondary transactions and distributed to investors.
  • Restricted ability for the adviser to charge certain fees or expenses. Fees or expenses associated with regulatory or governmental investigations or adviser exams to the private fund’s investors would be limited.
  • Restricted ability to give preferential treatment to certain investors. The ability to give discounted, or to waive, management and/or incentive fees, would be limited if it could negatively impact other investors that do not have such terms.
  • Annual requirement to document compliance in writing.

Why Did the Court Vacate the Rule?

The court stated the rule exceeded the SEC’s statutory authority because the laws on which it relied didn’t give the SEC such authority. "By congressional design, private funds are exempt from federal regulation of their internal governance structure,” wrote Judge Kurt Engelhardt.

The ruling was provided in response to a lawsuit brought last summer by a cohort of trade associations, including the Managed Funds Association, American Investment Council, National Association of Private Fund Managers, National Venture Capital Association, Alternative Investment Management Association, and the Loan Syndications and Trading Association. They argued the rules would fundamentally change the way private funds are regulated in the U.S. They claimed the rule would also effectively bar bespoke contractual terms investors negotiate to meet specific needs, and would prevent advisers from charging for certain expenses, ultimately requiring costly reporting they felt was unnecessary.

Impact on the Industry and Next Steps

There are always two sides to any story. The appealing trade associations, and many others, are applauding the court’s decision as a significant victory for private fund advisers and investors alike. Investors will continue to be able to negotiate tailored terms with private fund advisers to meet their specific needs, and advisers will avoid the costly implementation of the rule. Those in favor of the ruling also believe it’s a victory for U.S. businesses that look to private funds for investments/capital to grow. 

On the other hand, financial reform groups are disappointed, as they believe the rule would have provided investors with key protections and transparency, which has been the current SEC regime’s agenda over the past few years. Some of these investors include pension funds, which are essential to the retirement savings of policemen, firefighters and teachers.

From our perspective, we believe the SEC’s intent was to protect investors from practices that can often be viewed as opaque in the private fund world and to create more transparency. However, investors in such funds are typically high-net-worth individuals, trusts, accredited investors and sophisticated institutional clients that typically have the knowledge and resources to understand the complexities of the private funds in which they invest. This includes fund fee structures and expenses, which are currently shared and disclosed to investors through private placement memorandums, subscription agreements and other fund organizational agreements. These funds were not designed for the everyday retail investor, nor should they be, given the complexities and risks associated with these funds’ underlying investments. The SEC rule also would have ultimately resulted in higher costs to investors with additional compliance burden. 

We expect the SEC will carefully review this court ruling in detail and weigh the concerns of market participants before taking next steps. In the meantime, we will continue to monitor the developments on this ruling and its impact to those in the industry.

Read the complete trade associations’ petition 

Contact Syed Farooq or a member of your service team to discuss this topic further.

Cohen & Co is not rendering legal, accounting or other professional advice. Information contained in this post is considered accurate as of the date of publishing. Any action taken based on information in this blog should be taken only after a detailed review of the specific facts, circumstances and current law with your professional advisers.

About the Author

Syed Farooq, CPA

Partner, Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC
Partner, Cohen & Company, Ltd.
sfarooq@cohenco.com
312.277.7213

Related Insights

Article

The SEC’s New Rules — and Their Impact — for Private Fund Advisers 

Read More
Article

IRS Recommits to Scrutiny of Limited Partners Providing Services to Private Funds

Read More
Article

Regulatory Change and Retail Alternatives Center Stage at ICI Conference

Read More
Sign up for Our Investment Industry Services Newsletter

Receive insights from our team of investment industry services specialists directly to your inbox as they go live in our online Knowledge Center.

Subscribe Today
Top
Subscribe to our newsletter
About Contact Submit RFP Privacy Policy

"Cohen & Co" is the brand name under which Cohen & Company, Ltd. and Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC, and its subsidiary entities, provide professional services.

Cohen & Company, Ltd. and Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC practice in an alternative practice structure in accordance with the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct and applicable law, regulations and professional standards.

Cohen & Company, Ltd. is a licensed independent CPA firm that provides attest services to its clients. Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC and its subsidiary entities provide tax, advisory and business consulting services to their clients and are not licensed CPA firms.

The entities operating under the Cohen & Co brand are independently owned and are not responsible for the services provided by any other entity operating under the Cohen & Co brand. Our use of terms such as “our firm,” “we,” “us” and other terms of similar import denote the alternative practice structure of Cohen & Company, Ltd. and Cohen & Co Advisory, LLC.

© 2025 Cohen & Co